Aw, Amish Bread Pudding. What’s there not to like about this recipe from Glynis Jolly @Speculations Impressed, and just in time for all our family gatherings and celebrations. So here’s Glynis and her Amish Bread Pudding. Christmas is just one week away. If you’re like me, you’re probably expecting pies as the desserts for the feast meal. That’s the way it was when I was a kid, one pumpkin, one cherry and one mincemeat.